- We spent over 1,000 hours researching and testing the top mattresses on the market and consulting with 21 sleep experts to compile our recommendations.
- Our testers evaluated over 100 models and recorded our findings on a 42-question standardized testing form to identify standout features and services, document issues with each product, and describe our personal experience lying on each mattress.
- We paid close attention to specific considerations that sleepers of all ages seek, as identified by respondents in our survey of 600 mattress owners. This included price, features, and the set-up process.
- We rated hybrid mattresses based on the support provided by their inner core, the pressure relief and weight distribution provided by foam layers, along with edge support, responsiveness, and cooling capabilities.
Learn more about how we tested the best hybrid mattresses.
Key takeaways
- The Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid is our pick as the best overall hybrid mattress because of its performance in the categories that matter most to sleepers, including support, pressure relief, and cooling capabilities.
- Based on over 1,000 hours of testing and our survey of 600 mattress owners, we know that temperature regulation, responsiveness, and affordability to be important features to look for in hybrid mattresses.
- Hybrid mattresses can cost around $1,000 to over $3,000, depending on size, brand, and construction.
Finding the best mattress involves combining the right factors: support and feel, price, trial period, and personal preference. A hybrid mattress can be a winning part of this equation. Hybrid mattresses feature foam and innerspring coils, combining the best qualities of memory foam and spring mattresses.
“Memory foam is known for its pressure-relieving ability due to its slow response time,” said Craig Zettergren, MSPT, Dip. MDT, a physical therapist and regional vice president of FYZICAL Therapy & Balance Centers clinics. “Latex foam offers a firm yet supportive sensation. Pocket coils move independently of each other to provide resilient support. This unique combination of foams and coils helps to provide the most effective lumbar support for those experiencing back pain.”
The comfortable and supportive qualities of the best hybrid mattresses may help you get a good night’s sleep, even if back pain isn’t your primary concern. Our Reviews Team tested our recommended hybrid mattresses to ensure they’re worth the investment.
Our picks for the best hybrid mattresses
- Helix Midnight Luxe: Best Hybrid Mattress Overall
- Emma Hybrid Comfort Mattress: Best Affordable Hybrid Mattress
- Leesa Sapira Chill: Best Cooling Hybrid Mattress
- Bear Elite Hybrid: Most Comfortable Hybrid Mattress
- Titan Plus: Best Hybrid Mattress for Heavy People
- Birch Natural: Best Latex Hybrid Mattress
- The WinkBed: Best Hybrid Mattress for Couples
What to look for in hybrid mattresses
- Firmness: Firmness is rated on a 1 to 10 scale. But we have found this to be subjective, with different firmness needs varying from person to person. In a hybrid mattress, look for one that is firm enough to maintain spinal alignment in your preferred sleeping position.
- Pressure relief: A hybrid mattress will feel most comfortable if it evenly distributes weight, avoiding pressure build up on the hips, lower back, and shoulders.
- Price: Hybrid mattresses are typically more expensive than memory foam and innerspring mattresses, costing between $1,000 and $3,000 each. We found there are a few affordable hybrid mattress options that are still high quality because online brands like Brooklyn Bedding often offer promotion discounts.
- Motion isolation: Light sleepers who share a bed with a partner, child, or pet, will appreciate an option with good motion isolation. This prevents motion transfer when there is movement in one area of the bed.
Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid: Best hybrid mattress overall
Why Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid is our pick for best hybrid mattress overall
We chose the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid as the best hybrid mattress overall because of its high scores across most testing categories. We found it to be a true medium-firm mattress and appreciated the extra support in the lumbar region. During testing, we noted easy movement thanks to the responsiveness of the bed balanced with great motion isolation.
Who should consider the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid: Because of the medium-firm support of this mattress, we think it is a great choice for side and back sleepers, and that the motion isolation would improve comfort for coupled sleepers.
Who should consider other options: Because of the soft surface of this hybrid mattress, it may not be supportive enough to maintain spine neutrality for most stomach sleepers.
Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid tester insights
The Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid mattress’s medium firmness may appeal to a variety of sleeper types. Our testers found the bed’s gentle contouring and supportive coils made it especially good for back and side sleepers. We also found it responsive to weight and movement, allowing combination sleepers to reposition themselves without feeling “stuck” in the mattress. We recommend this bed for couples because it has solid edge support and good motion isolation, making it less likely that partners will wake each other while shifting position or getting out of bed.
Although memory foam can trap heat, the materials and construction of this bed work in tandem to provide excellent temperature regulation. Saatva has infused its foam with cooling gel, and the coils provide the needed airflow to prevent heat from getting trapped within the materials.
From one of our Saatva testers:
“The Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid provides hug-like contouring, but it is also incredibly responsive. This gives sleepers top-notch comfort and allows them to reposition easily and quickly. This mattress shouldn’t make you feel stuck in it.”
While the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid is our best overall pick because of its features and performance, we have not yet found the perfect mattress. With that in mind, there are better picks for stomach sleepers, who typically need a firmer mattress. The Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid is too soft to lift the majority of stomach sleepers’ hips sufficiently. As such, the middle of the body can sag too far into the mattress, causing awkward and uncomfortable spinal alignment.
Learn more in our Saatva mattress review.
Puffy Lux Hybrid: Best hybrid mattress for side sleepers
Why Puffy Lux Hybrid is our pick for best hybrid mattress for side sleepers
We chose the Puffy Lux Hybrid as the best hybrid mattress for side sleepers because its medium firmness level provides just enough cushion and contour to offer pressure relief in this sleeping position. During testing, we found that the mattress gently cradles the body of average-weight side sleepers, but the coils in the mattress’s core prevent the body from sinking too far into the mattress.
Who should consider the Puffy Lux Hybrid: Side sleepers will find this mattress contours to their curves while maintaining spine alignment.
Who should consider other options: Since the full price of the queen-sized Puffy Lux Hybrid is $2,849, this mattress is not a great choice for someone looking for an affordable model.
Puffy Lux Hybrid tester insights
Side sleepers need substantial pressure relief around the parts of their bodies that are in constant contact with the mattress throughout the night—the shoulders and hips. The plush, gentle hug of the Puffy Lux Hybrid’s foam layers makes this bed a standout in that regard. Beneath the cloud-like softness of the foam is a base of coils. This design prevents most side sleepers from sinking too far into the bed, which can lead to uncomfortable spinal alignment and pressure buildup.
From one of our Puffy testers:
“The Puffy Lux Hybrid is a bed we are excited about. It has cloud-like foam layers for cuddly comfort and responsive coils that provide ample bounce.”
The Puffy Lux Hybrid is a great choice for light- and average-weight side sleepers, but it’s too soft for higher-weight and stomach sleepers. These folks typically need a firmer mattress that will elevate their hips properly. Even with the supportive coil base, the softness of the Puffy Lux Hybrid could lead to these sleepers sinking into the layers a bit too much, leading to aches and pains from the lack of lumbar and hip support.
To learn more about Puffy mattresses, read our Puffy Cloud review.
Helix Dawn Luxe: Best hybrid mattress for back pain
Why Helix Dawn Luxe is our pick for best hybrid mattress for back pain
We chose the Helix Dawn Luxe as the best hybrid mattress for back pain because we feel the zoned lumber support paired with the soft pillow top is just right for sleepers with back pain. We also noticed that inner coils and edge support work together in this mattress to improve responsiveness, so it is easier for individuals with back pain related mobility issues to reposition or get out of bed.
Who should consider the Helix Dawn Luxe: Individuals with lower back pain will appreciate how the plush surface of this mattress works together with zoned lumbar support target at the lower back.
Who should consider other options: We found the 7.5 firmness level of this mattress to be too firm for side sleeping, which requires a level of softness that contours to the body while maintaining a neutral spine.
Helix Dawn Luxe tester insights
The Helix Dawn Luxe gets our vote for the best hybrid mattress for back pain because its coils are designed for zoned support, meaning that sleepers will receive more support around their back and hips. This construction choice provides top-notch spinal alignment and lumbar pressure relief.
Our testers rolled a pressure map on top of the Helix Dawn Luxe to see how much pressure builds up around the side, back, and stomach when lying on this mattress. Our tests showed that the Helix Dawn Luxe is a solid hybrid mattress choice for many people with back pain, particularly those who prefer sleeping on their backs or stomachs.
We also like this mattress for its excellent edge support. Solid edge support provides security when sleeping toward the outside of the bed and makes it easier to get out of bed. The Helix Dawn Luxe has a reinforced layer of pocketed coils around the bed’s perimeter to better support people with mobility issues due to back pain or other conditions.
From one of our Helix testers:
“A mattress is a significant investment, and you certainly don’t want to wake up with an aching back after purchasing a new one. The Helix Dawn Luxe expertly combines a soft top with a zoned support layer designed to help ease a problematic back.”
Although the Helix Dawn Luxe is firm enough to ease back pain, it does offer some cushioning thanks to the contouring foam layers. However, if you prefer the feeling of being “hugged” that comes from a softer, contouring mattress, you may want to take another look at the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid.
The Helix Dawn Luxe is on the more expensive side. Although the durable materials may make it worth the higher cost, this bed may be more than some people are comfortable paying. For those willing to pay the higher price tag, Helix recently added in-home setup and removal, though the service is currently only available in certain areas.
![A woman uses a measuring tape to measure the height and thickness of a Helix mattress]](https://d1xpftaradk20j.cloudfront.net/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/Helix-Hybrid.jpg)
Learn more in our Helix mattress review.
Nolah Natural: Best latex hybrid mattress
Why Nolah Natural is our pick for best latex hybrid mattress
We chose the Nolah Natural as the best latex hybrid mattress because of Nolah’s commitment to eco-friendly, natural materials in every mattress they sell. This mattress uses a naturally derived Talalay latex in place of memory foam, which is responsive and provides good pressure relief. At the same time, the material choices in the model make it hypoallergenic and reduces off-gassing smell associated with new mattress purchases.
Who should consider the Nolah Natural: The firmer nature of this mattress makes it a good choice for back and stomach sleepers who value naturally derived materials in their mattresses.
Who should consider other options: We rated the firmness level of the Nolah Natural a 7, which will be too firm for most side sleepers and lighter weight sleepers.
Nolah Natural tester insights
Purchasing the Nolah Natural, a bed made with natural Talalay latex, benefits both you and the planet. However, Nolah doesn’t stop its eco-friendliness there. This organic mattress is free of harmful chemicals and substances, and it’s made with GOTS-certified organic wool, organic cotton, and recycled steel.
The open-cell structure of Talalay latex makes it a naturally cool material. In the Nolah Natural, the latex layer and coil system work in tandem to create a breathable bed that prevents heat from building up and allowing for exemplary airflow. Furthermore, our testers found the Talalay latex responsive, and the coils add plenty of bounce, making this a great bed for combination sleepers and sexually active couples.
From one of our Nolah testers:
“As a hot sleeper, I appreciate how well this bed regulates temperature. Furthermore, I am impressed with how durable and eco-friendly the Nolah Natural is.”
The Nolah Natural falls a little short when it comes to isolating motion, though. Although it isn’t terrible, it’s enough that co-sleepers are likely to feel their partners tossing and turning. Our Handbook Team advises a firmer bed for stomach sleepers, as the Nolah Natural may be too soft to lift the midsection, which could lead to a hyper-extended spine and back pain.
Titan Plus: Best hybrid mattress for heavy people
Why Titan Plus is our pick for best hybrid mattress for heavy people
We chose the Titan Plus as the best hybrid mattress for heavy people because the individually encased coils provide the firm support and durability important in mattresses for heavier people. We also noted that the added layers of memory and comfort foam add a luxury feeling of plushness, preventing pressure build up with excellent weight distribution.
Who should consider the Titan Plus: The Titan Plus is a good choice for average to heavier weight people because of its firmness level and durable innerspring core.
Who should consider other options: During testing, we noticed the Titan Plus scores lower in temperature regulation, so it may not be a good fit for sleepers who tend to run hot.
Titan Plus tester insights
Firmness is subjective, and a bed’s hardness or softness can differ depending on your body type. We evaluated the Titan Plus using an average-weight and heavy-weight person. Although our higher-weight tester sank into the softer foam layers more than the average-weight tester did, both agreed that the Titan Plus had a solidly firm feel.
The Titan Plus offers deep compression for sleepers with larger bodies while keeping the hips elevated and the spine aligned in all sleep positions. Our Handbook Team believes this bed can provide the support stomach sleepers need to prevent their midsections from sinking too far into the bed, as well as exceptional comfort and support for average- to higher-weight people.
The Titan Plus performed well on motion isolation tests, making it a good option for couples. One partner’s movements aren’t likely to disturb the other. It also had good edge support, which allows couples to utilize the entire surface of their mattress.
From one of our Titan testers:
“The firm Titan Plus Mattress is a fantastic mattress for folks weighing more than 250 pounds, dedicated stomach sleepers, and those with back pain. Couples may also enjoy how well the foam layers absorb their partner’s movements.”
Shoppers who prefer feeling enveloped by their bed probably won’t be fans of the Titan Plus, as it provides a firm “on top” of the mattress feel. Because of this, we don’t recommend the Titan Plus for side sleepers, especially petite ones, who need more cushion in their mattress top. The mattress’s firmness could lead to pressure build-up for these sleepers.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid: Best affordable hybrid mattress
Why Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is our pick for best affordable hybrid mattress
We chose the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid as the best affordable hybrid mattress because of the budget-friendly price tag and regular discounts. Even though this is the lowest-priced mattress on our list, we were still impressed with how it performed in testing. Specifically, this model scored high in pressure relief as well as temperature regulation. It may be too soft for some stomach sleepers but provides enough support to maintain spine neutrality for back and side sleepers.
Who should consider the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid: Sleepers who are shopping with a strict budget will find the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is an affordable, comfortable, and supportive option.
Who should consider other options: This mattress is a medium on the firmness scale, so it might not provide enough support for heavy sleepers and stomach sleepers.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid tester insights
Your budget should not determine whether you get a good night’s rest. Thanks to the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid, you can sleep soundly without breaking the bank. Our testers loved that a reasonably priced bed has three firmness options to choose from, so shoppers can find the bed that fits them best. This versatility, combined with quality materials, proves that a bed doesn’t have to cost a fortune to provide a quality sleep environment.
We ran this affordable mattress through a battery of tests. It’s constructed with hyper-elastic comfort foam, proprietary VariFlex transition foam (high-density foam that’s designed with deep compression support), and hundreds of 8-inch, individually encased coils. It performed well across the board, but it shined in both motion isolation and bounce. We were a little surprised this bed did so well in both categories because we have found that beds are often either bouncy or absorb motion well, rarely both. Our team recommends this bed for sexually active couples and co-sleepers who have a restless partner.
From one of our Brooklyn Bedding testers:
“We love how responsive the Signature Hybrid is. After applying weight, the foam immediately pops back up, making it fairly effortless to move around on this bed.”
Although the edge is supportive, one tester said they didn’t feel it was firm enough to sleep there comfortably. This would not be a problem for people who sleep toward the middle of the bed, but it could be problematic for people who like to utilize the full bed or have mobility issues and need a firmer edge to balance on.
The WinkBed: Best hybrid king mattress
Why The WinkBed is our pick for best hybrid king mattress
We chose The WinkBed as the best hybrid king mattress because it is a versatile option available in three firmness levels. We also know that larger beds are a popular choice for partnered sleepers, and this model gets high ratings in categories often important to couples, like motion isolation, edge support, and cooling capabilities. The WinkBed also got an above-average score in the category of bounce, which lends itself to natural and easy movement during sex.
Who should consider The WinkBed: The WinkBed is a good choice for someone with a larger space who is sharing a bed with a partner, children, or pets.
Who should consider other options: Because this mattress doesn’t do a good job contouring the body, it won’t be a comfortable choice for many side sleepers.
The WinkBed tester insights
Stretching out in bed after a long day is a great feeling, and for those who want to maximize their sleeping space, a king-size bed is the way to go. Our Handbook Team chose The WinkBed, a hybrid with three firmness options, as the best king mattress because of its quality, durability, and overall construction. This bed also has excellent cooling properties and strong edge support, so you can use more of the mattress, a key factor for those who share their beds with a partner or a pet, or who have mobility issues.
Our testing indicates that this bed is slightly firmer than medium-firm. We gave it a firmness score of six out of 10. One of our testers said the mattress did a great job of supporting their lumbar region, which makes it a good choice for back sleepers and people with back pain. The WinkBed’s 13.5-inch height gives it a luxurious look, and according to our testers, the Tencel cover and gel-infused foams make sleepers feel like they’re resting on a cool cloud.
From one of our WinkBed testers:
“I loved how evenly distributed my weight felt on the WinkBed. Also, the cooling properties, from the Tencel cover to the gel infused foam, of this bed are a great feature. I don’t think many people will need to worry about overheating when sleeping on the WinkBed.”
If you prefer the gentle, slow-moving feel of a traditional memory foam mattress, the sturdy support structure and coil layers of The WinkBed may not provide enough sinkage or contouring for you. Also, king mattresses are the most expensive standard size, and The WinkBed is on the pricier side. Budget shoppers may need to consider another brand like Brooklyn Bedding.
Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid: Best hybrid mattress in a box
Why the Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid is our pick for best hybrid mattress in a box
We chose the Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid as the best hybrid mattress in a box because it provides ease of delivery and setup along with a night of supportive, comfortable sleep. This mattress earned high scores in the category of pressure relief after we observed excellent weight distribution during testing. Thanks to the copper present in the cover, the Nectar Premier has impressive cooling capabilities.
Who should consider the Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid: Individuals seeking a bed-in-a-box that provides medium support for back and side sleepers will appreciate the convenience of the Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid.
Who should consider other options: During testing, this mattress received a true medium firmness rating, making it too soft to maintain spinal alignment for most stomach sleepers.
Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid tester insights
After the Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid is delivered to your door and takes its shape, you have a full year to decide if it’s right for you. If, within those 365 days, you decide it’s not the best choice for you, you can return it. The stress-free convenience of this setup is a big perk for many online mattress shoppers.
From one of our Nectar testers:
“The Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid is compressed, rolled, and then placed in a box before being sent to your front porch. Once you have set up your mattress, you will have a full year to decide if it is giving you quality sleep.”
This luxury mattress uses copper infusions, slow-moving memory foam, and sturdy coils to give sleepers a cool, contouring, and supportive night’s rest. This bed is ideal for light-weight and average-weight back sleepers and average-weight side sleepers. Those with back pain may also benefit from the Nectar Premier Copper Hybrid. Additionally, the mattress has substantial edge support, which may be appealing to couples and people with mobility issues. The cooling copper infusions are designed to help keep sleepers cool even when sleeping with a partner or pet.
“Side sleepers and back sleepers generally benefit from medium-soft to medium-firm mattresses to provide adequate support to the hips and shoulders, areas that bear more pressure in this position, while allowing for enough contouring to align the spine properly.”
Teresa Denike,a board-certified clinical sleep educator and founder of Sleep Better NYC
Although many people will be pleased with the convenience of the Nectar bed in a box, we understand this is not a one-size-fits-all mattress. Budget shoppers and people who prefer to sleep on their stomachs, or who like the gentle hug of memory foam beds, may want to look at other mattresses before they click “add to cart.”
Read our Nectar Mattress review for more information.
Nolah Evolution: Best plush hybrid mattress
Why the Nolah Evolution is our pick for best plush hybrid mattress
We chose the Nolah Evolution as the best plush hybrid mattress because of the luxury feel of this soft-to-the-touch model. We appreciate that this same design is accessible to a variety of sleepers since Nolah offers this model in three firmness levels. During testing, we noticed this mattress was fairly responsive, bouncing back quickly after pressure applied. This is a great feature for a plush mattress, preventing sleepers from feeling like they are “stuck” in their mattress when they’d like to reposition or get out of bed.
Who should consider the Nolah Evolution: Because of the plush nature of this mattress, we think it is a great fit for light to average weight sleepers who prefer to sleep on their side or back.
Who should consider other options: The Nolah Evolution received average ratings in the category of motion transfer, so we think couples who are sensitive to the movement of their partner might find other models better suited to their needs.
Nolah Evolution tester insights
Nolah is a tech-driven brand, and the Evolution is its first foray into hybrid mattresses. But don’t let their hybrid rookie status fool you—our testers gave this hybrid bed a stellar rating. We love that there are three firmness options so sleepers have a choice when it comes to the level that works best for them. For lighter-weight and side sleepers, the Plush version of this bed is an excellent pick.
The AirFoamICE is designed to keep sleepers cool and relieve pressure on the hips, shoulders, and lower back. This bed also has great motion isolation, making it an excellent mattress for couples who want to sleep soundly with a restless partner.
From one of our Nolah testers:
“The Evolution is packed with softness. Layer after layer offers plush relief.”
This mattress may be too plush for heavy-weight and stomach sleepers as they may sink too far into the layers, leaving their spines in a compromising and uncomfortable position.
Our testers noted a chemical smell when they unboxed the Nolah, but it’s nothing to be alarmed about. The smell is known as off-gassing. It may be an unpleasant scent for some people, but it isn’t harmful, and it should dissipate in a couple of days. Place it in a ventilated area if you want to air it out at a quicker pace.
DreamCloud Premier: Best hybrid mattress for couples
Why the DreamCloud Premier is our pick for best hybrid mattress for couples
We chose the DreamCloud Premier as the best hybrid mattress for couples because it excelled in testing categories beneficial for people who share beds. Couples tend to appreciate motion isolation, so their movements in bed don’t disturb their partner, and this model got top marks in this testing category. At the same time, we felt it had good responsiveness and bounce, promoting natural movement during sex. At a competitive price point, we were pleasantly surprised by just how luxurious laying on this mattress felt.
Who should consider the DreamCloud Premier: Light sleepers who share a bed with a partner, child, or pet will appreciate that the DreamCloud Premier does a great job isolating motion.
Who should consider other options: We didn’t observe great temperature regulation during testing and feel hot sleepers might find this model to be a little too warm.
DreamCloud Premier tester insights
Our testers found that the layers of foam in the DreamCloud Premier do a great job of reducing motion transfer, meaning co-sleepers will be relatively undisturbed by a restless partner’s twists and turns. The reliable edge support in this bed allows couples to utilize the entire sleeping surface and makes it easier for people with mobility issues to get out of bed from a place of stability. At the same time, the coils provide extra responsiveness that will help sexually active couples move and reposition with little effort.
The high-quality materials indicate that this bed has staying power, and our testers said the cashmere cover and Euro pillow made a big difference in comfort.
From one of our DreamCloud testers:
“This mattress just feels luxurious. The cashmere cover is a lovely touch.”
Although the DreamCloud Premier has features not typically found in hybrid mattresses, some of our testers said they wish DreamCloud had invested in cooling properties a little more. Our testers found that while the bed doesn’t sleep hot, it was still warmer than the other hybrid mattresses we tested.
Learn more in our DreamCloud mattress review.
How we test and choose the best mattresses
Our Reviews Team spent over 1,000 hours researching over 100 different mattresses, taking into account the experiences of the 600 mattress owners we surveyed. We also conducted detailed interviews with individuals who have used these mattresses and consulted with over 21 experts who understand the importance of a good night’s sleep. We know health rests on a foundation of good sleep, and feel a comfortable and supportive mattress is an important part of a holistic approach to physical and mental health.
First-hand testing experience
Our Reviews Team performs hands-on testing of every mattress we review to help you find the most comfortable and supportive hybrid mattress. We evaluate each model independently, using a 42-question standardized testing form to identify standout features and services, document issues with each product, and describe our personal experience lying on each mattress. For example, we look at the firmness of each mattress to see if the reported firmness level is true to our tester’s experience. We use a 10-pound ball to observe the bounce of each mattress for ease of movement. We also know that cooling capabilities can be hit or miss in mattresses containing memory foam, so we use a thermal gun to measure the temperature of a mattress before and after spending time on the bed to see if the cooling properties perform in a way that matches the brand’s marketing promises.
Mattress surveys & interviews
Comfort is a subjective experience and individual preferences and circumstances play a big role in how each person feels on a mattress. We want to get an accurate picture of how the models we reviewed perform in day-to-day life, so we pay close attention to specific considerations that sleepers of all ages seek, as identified by respondents in our survey of 600 mattress owners. This included price, features, and the set-up process. We also interview real people to better understand the motivations behind shopping for a new mattress as well as the benefits of purchasing one.
Objective and honest ratings
We know that everyone has different needs for their holistic health and that a mattress should be tailored to each person. Even so, we found certain factors that are important across the board.
Using survey results and information gleaned from interviews and consultations with experts, we captured the most important features of a new mattress. We weigh these factors to develop a mattress scorecard and use those individual scores to determine an overall rating for each model we recommend. Every model in this roundup scored a minimum of 8 out of 10 for its overall rating.
| Factor | Weight | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Customer Service | 15% | Customer care center hours, support options |
| Brand Reputation | 10% | Years in business, lawsuits & class actions against this company |
| Features | 20% | Size options, firmness options, weight capacity, add-ons included (free sleep accessories) |
| User Experience | 35% | White glove delivery, CERTIPUR-US certifications, risk-free trials |
| Affordability | 20% | Price, warranty, promotions |
Learn more about our hybrid mattress testing and review methodology.
Our hybrid mattress testing process
Purchase mattress as mystery shoppers.
Set up mattress in testing lab.
Lie on mattress and rank firmness.
Lie on back, side, and stomach to find the best sleeping position.
Place 10-pound ball in mattress center and measure sinkage.
Find biggest pressure points using pressure map reading.
Evaluate cooling capabilities by recording temperature differences.
Drop 10-pound ball onto mattress to measure bounce score.
Test motion isolation.
Test edge support.
Calculate composite “sex” and “family” scores.
What are hybrid mattresses made of?
Hybrid mattresses take the best characteristics of innerspring and memory foam designs and combine them to create a bed balancing responsiveness and pressure relief with support and durability. More specifically, hybrids have a foundational core of durable innerspring coils that may be layered, individually pocketed, or encased. On top of the core, there are layers of memory and support foam to add softness and pressure relief, followed by what is typically some kind of quilted cover or pillowtop.
Hybrid mattresses compared to other mattress types
- Innerspring mattresses: While both innerspring and hybrid mattresses have coils, a hybrid also has added layers of memory and support foam. As a mattress that is primarily made up of coils, innerspring models tend to be firmer than hybrid. See our full innerspring mattress guide.
- Foam mattresses: Memory foam and hybrid mattresses both contain layers of foam, but a hybrid also has an innerspring core. We have found that the added component of the coils improves the durability of hybrid mattresses and increases their firmness. See our full memory foam mattress guide.
- Latex mattresses: A latex mattress uses latex as a replacement for memory foam. It is possible to find a mattress that is entirely latex foam, similar to a memory foam mattress, or one that is combined with coils as a latex hybrid. Latex tends to be more expensive but has both a naturally cooling and buoyant feel. See our full latex mattress guide.
How to choose a mattress for a good night’s sleep
Choosing a new mattress is a big decision. The right mattress will last you more than ten years, supporting your overall well-being along the way by promoting restful sleep. We know each person is unique, as are their preferences for a new mattress, but there are a few considerations we suggest you keep in mind while you shop.
Sleeping position
Your preferred sleeping position plays a part in what type of mattress will feel most comfortable to you.
- Stomach sleepers: Stomach sleepers tend to require a firmer mattress that is able to provide enough support to the hips to maintain a neutral spine. See our full stomach sleeper mattress guide.
- Side sleepers: A hybrid mattress with a medium-soft to medium firmness level will contour to the curves of the body, providing pressure relief while maintaining spine alignment. See our full side sleeper mattress guide.
- Back sleepers: Back sleepers often desire a hybrid mattress that is firm, while still cushioning their lower back, as that design feels most comfortable. See our full back sleeper mattress guide.
Sleeper’s body
Comfort and firmness in a mattress are subjective. A sleeper’s body type and medical history can change how they feel in a bed.
- Weight: Heavier people experience a mattress as less firm than an average-weight person, while lighter people experience a mattress as firmer. See our full mattresses for heavy sleepers guide.
- Age: Firmer mattresses are better suited for small bodies, and very young children are safer in a bed with no plushness or sinkage. See our full mattresses for kids guide.
- Health conditions: Individuals with chronic pain may benefit from a bed with zoned support to address this pain and will find that a responsive bed improves ease of movement as they reposition for comfort. See our full guides on mattresses for back pain and mattresses for hip pain.
Temperature
The memory foam present in hybrid mattresses has a tendency to trap heat, increasing the temperature of the sleeper, but added cooling properties can mitigate this issue. If you run hot, take a look at our in-depth reviews of the best cooling mattresses.
Price
Hybrid mattresses are typically more expensive than innerspring and memory foam models, costing between $1,000 and $3,000 each. Online brands often run promotions and the best affordable mattress balances budget with quality. On the other end of the spectrum, some mattress models pull out all the stops to ensure buyers receive their best night’s sleep. Learn more about our search for the best luxury mattress.
Our final verdict
Through thorough testing and research, we chose the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid as the best hybrid mattress overall after giving it high ratings in all of our mattress testing categories and an overall rating of 9.8. Hybrid mattresses are well loved for their versatility, and the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid is no exception. It provides enough support, responsiveness, and pressure relief for a variety of sleep positions and body types.
Although the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid isn’t the most affordable option on this list, it is regularly marked down at a deep discount to increase its affordability. We also appreciate Saatva’s industry-leading policies, as this company offers a lifetime warranty, a 365-night sleep trial, and free white glove delivery with every new mattress.
Compare the best hybrid mattresses in 2024
| Price | $1,295–$2,790 | $2,249-$3,448 | $1,373–$2,873 | $1,499–$3,398 | $699–$1,598 | $665–$1,664 | $1,149–$2,049 | $1,799–$3,898 | $1,499–$3,198 | $1,169–$2,998 |
| Firmness | 6.5/10 | 5.5/10 | 7.5/10 | 6/10 | 7.5/10 | 6/10 | 6.5/10 | 6/10 | 5/10 | 5.5/10 |
| Material | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid | Hybrid |
| Warranty | Lifetime | Lifetime | 10 years | Lifetime | 10 years | 10 years | Lifetime | Lifetime | Lifetime | 10 years |
| Trial period | 365 nights | 101 nights | 100 nights | 120 nights | 120 nights | 120 nights | 120 nights | 365 nights | 120 nights | 365 nights |
| Best for | Couples | Side Sleepers | Those with back pain | Combination sleepers | Heavy-weight sleepers | Budget shoppers | Couples | Back sleepers | Light-weight sleepers | Couples |
Frequently asked questions
Hybrid mattresses can be a great choice for many types of sleepers. However, there are some drawbacks to be aware of before purchasing one. The construction and materials in hybrid mattresses can make them more expensive than some other types of beds. Also, if you like the gentle contouring of memory foam beds or the traditional feel of an innerspring mattress, hybrids may not be the best fit for you. Another drawback of a hybrid mattress is that it can be heavier than standard mattresses. This wouldn’t necessarily be a problem on a daily basis, but it could make it more difficult to move.
The type of bed that works best for you is based on personal preference, body type, and sleep position, among other concerns. Since hybrids combine materials from memory foam, latex, and innerspring mattresses, they are versatile and make a great choice for many sleepers.
It is not advisable to put your hybrid mattress on a box spring. Box springs lack a solid, stable surface and likely won’t provide the kind of base your hybrid mattress needs. It’s important to note that some hybrid manufacturers will void the warranty if you use a box spring with your mattress.
The length of time that your hybrid mattress will last depends on several factors, including the quality of materials, durability of construction, and the amount of use it gets. On average, a well-made hybrid should last seven to 10 years.
Hybrid mattresses combine a supportive, innerspring coil with layers of memory foam. Because of this, they often provide enough support to promote spine neutrality in a variety of sleep positions, while still cushioning and contouring the body for comfort and pressure relief.
During testing, we found the Saatva Memory Foam Hybrid to be the best hybrid mattress overall, but we know this model might not be the best fit for all sleepers. Each person is unique with their own comfort preferences, but the best hybrid mattress is one that can support spinal alignment, relieve pressure on joints, and give you a sound night’s sleep.
- Zhang, Y., Xiao, A., Zheng, T., Xiao, H., & Huang, R. (2022b). The relationship between sleeping position and sleep quality: A flexible sensor-based study. Sensors, 22(16), 6220. Link
- Scott, A.J., Webb, T.L., Martyn-St James, M., Rowse, G., & Weich, S. (2021). Improving sleep quality leads to better mental health: A meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. Sleep Medicine Reviews, 60, 101556. Link
- Good Sleep for Good Health. (2021, April). National Institute of Health. Link
- Fuentes, B., Kennedy, K., Killgore, W., Wills, C., Grandner, M. (2022). Bed Sharing Versus Sleeping Alone Associated with Sleep Health and Mental Health. Sleep, 45(1), A4. Link